De'Longhi Magnifica Start vs Evo

We earn a commission if you buy through a link on this page. It costs you nothing extra and it does not change what we recommend. Full disclosure.

Same range, milk is the divider

The Magnifica Start and the Magnifica Evo are two tiers of the same De'Longhi bean-to-cup range, not two unrelated machines. Both are super-automatics — they grind fresh beans, dose, tamp and brew a shot at the press of a button — and both make genuinely good, genuinely automatic espresso. So the espresso itself is not where your decision lives. The single feature that separates these tiers, and the one that drives almost all the buyer regret in this category, is milk: specifically, whether the machine froths it for you or makes you do it yourself. Get that one detail right and the rest of the choice is easy; get it wrong and you will be disappointed no matter how good the coffee is.

The Start is the cheapest way into De'Longhi's bean-to-cup range, and it is in our spec database, so here are its specs traced to De'Longhi's own documentation. Note what the table does and does not tell you: it confirms the automatic brewing and the grinder, but the milk on the Start is a manual frother, which is the crux we unpack next.

If you have not yet decided that a super-automatic is even the right category — rather than a semi-automatic you drive by hand — settle that first in our guide to choosing a super-automatic. Everything below assumes you want the machine to grind, tamp and brew for you, and you are now choosing between the Start and the Evo tier of the Magnifica line. We compare them on the four things that genuinely differ: the milk system first, then drink range, interface and price.

Milk system: the honest crux

This is the whole decision, so we lead with it plainly. The Magnifica Start has a manual frother— a steam-wand-style pannarello you hold the jug under and froth yourself. The espresso is fully automatic, but the milk is not, so a "one-touch cappuccino" is not what the Start delivers. You make the espresso at a button, then texture and pour the milk by hand, the same as you would on a semi-automatic. Plenty of people are happy with that — some prefer the control — but it is the opposite of hands-free, and assuming otherwise is the most common reason people return a super-automatic.

The Evo is the step up, and it is the tier where automatic milk becomes possible— but read that carefully, because possible is not the same as guaranteed. De'Longhi's automatic LatteCremacarafe, which textures and pours milk into the cup hands-free, appears only on the milk-equipped versions of the Evo (and higher trims such as the Magnifica Plus). A plain Evo without the LatteCrema carafe still froths by hand, exactly like the Start. So "buy an Evo" on its own does not get you automatic milk — you have to buy a LatteCrema-equipped Evo specifically. This is the single most important sentence on the page: automatic milk starts at the Evo tier, and only on the milk versions.

The practical takeaway: if a genuinely hands-free cappuccino is non-negotiable, you must climb to a LatteCrema-equipped Evo and check the listing carefully — neither the Start nor a plain Evo will do it. If you are happy to froth milk yourself, the Start gets you automatic espresso for the least money by leaving the milk manual, and you are not losing any espresso quality by choosing it. How De'Longhi's milk systems compare with the other big bean-to-cup brand is covered in our Philips vs De'Longhi super-automatic guide, which is worth a read if you have not locked in the brand yet.

Drink range

Beyond milk, the Evo tier widens the one-touch drink menu compared with the Start. The Start keeps things focused — espresso and coffee at a button, with the milk drinks left to you and your frother — which is genuinely all a lot of households order. The Evo adds more pre-programmed recipes, and on the LatteCrema versions those recipes extend to hands-free milk drinks like cappuccino and latte macchiato at a single press. If your day is an espresso and one milk drink you are happy to froth, the Start covers you. If you want a longer, café-style menu poured for you, that is what the milk-equipped Evo adds.

The honest framing is the same as anywhere in this category: drink count is a convenience feature, not a quality one. Both tiers grind fresh at every drink and pull broadly similar espresso; the dearer machine simply turns more drinks into a single, named press. So decide how many genuinely different drinks your household actually orders. If it is really espresso and one milk drink, you are paying for menu entries you will not use by reaching past the Start — unless the milk being automatic is itself the feature you want, which is the real reason to move up.

Interface and daily use

The two tiers present themselves a little differently in daily use. The Start keeps a simple, legible control layout that gets you to its handful of drinks without much learning, which suits a first-time bean-to-cup owner who just wants coffee. The Evo generally offers a fuller, more guided interface to match its longer menu and, on the LatteCrema versions, its automatic milk drinks. Neither is difficult; the Start is arguably easier precisely because it does less, while the Evo's richer controls are the price of the extra drinks and the automatic milk it can carry.

Daily upkeep is broadly similar across both, with one meaningful fork at the milk. Both share an internal brewing unit, a drip tray and grounds bin to empty, and regular descaling — none of it onerous by super-automatic standards. On the manual-frother Start there is no milk carafe to wash, just a wand to purge and wipe after each drink, which some people actually prefer. On a LatteCrema Evo you gain a detachable, dishwasher-friendly milk carafe that typically auto-rinses its milk path — more convenient to use, but one more part to keep clean. That trade — a wand to wipe versus a carafe to rinse — is worth picturing honestly, because you will live with it every day.

Price and what the step-up buys

The Start is the entry price of the range and the Evo sits above it, with the LatteCrema milk versions of the Evo higher still. By now the value question answers itself: the step up is not buying you better espresso — it is buying more one-touch drinks, a fuller interface and, crucially, the option of automatic LatteCrema milk. That makes it a clean decision. If a hands-free cappuccino is the point of the whole purchase, a LatteCrema Evo is worth the money and the Start will frustrate you. If you are content to froth milk yourself, the Start gets you the same automatic espresso for the least outlay, and the Evo's extras are ones you can skip.

Because prices move, check the two live prices above rather than assuming a fixed gap, and remember that within the Evo tier the LatteCrema (automatic milk) versions cost more than the manual-frother ones — so the real price ladder is Start, then plain Evo, then LatteCrema Evo. For the fuller De'Longhi picture, the Magnifica range in depth — every tier and where the automatic milk actually starts — is on the De'Longhi Magnifica hub, and both machines sit against the wider bean-to-cup field in our best super-automatic machines roundup.

Honest cons on each

Where the Start frustrates.The obvious one is the milk: it froths by hand, so anyone who bought it expecting a one-touch cappuccino will be let down, and that mismatch is the most common regret in the category. Its drink menu is short, so more of your variety comes from adjusting settings rather than pressing a dedicated recipe. And, like every machine in the range, its sealed brewing unit gives you no real control over the shot beyond grind and strength — the ceiling of the whole super-automatic category, not a flaw unique to the Start.

Where the Evo frustrates.The biggest one is the confusion built into the tier: "Evo" alone does not tell you whether the milk is automatic, because some Evo versions froth by hand and only the LatteCrema-equipped ones pour milk for you. Buyers who assume any Evo means hands-free milk get caught out. The LatteCrema carafe, when you do get it, has more internal plumbing to keep clean than a simple wand, and the milk-equipped Evo costs meaningfully more than the Start. Both tiers share the category's real limit: a super-automatic makes good, consistent espresso with almost no skill, but it cannot pour latte art (the milk goes straight into the cup) and cannot match the top of what a person pulls on a semi-automatic with a dedicated grinder. If that ceiling matters, you are choosing the wrong category, not the wrong tier.

Who is fine with the Start, and who should pay up

Lead with the milk, because it decides the most. Buy the Magnifica Startif you want automatic espresso at the lowest price in the range and you are genuinely happy to froth milk by hand — or you mostly drink espresso and black coffee and rarely make milk drinks at all. You lose nothing on espresso quality by choosing it, and for a lot of buyers the manual frother is a fair trade for the saving. It is the value pick, and if a one-touch cappuccino is not your priority, it is very likely the right one.

Step up to a LatteCrema-equipped Evoif a genuinely hands-free milk drink is the point — if you want to press one button and have a finished cappuccino or latte macchiato poured for you, or if several people in a busy household want a range of milk drinks without learning to froth. In a family kitchen where the machine has to be effortless for everyone, that automatic milk and the longer menu are exactly what the extra money buys; our best machines for a familyshortlist leans on precisely those traits. Whichever way you go, buy for the milk experience you actually want, and — on the Evo — confirm the exact model carries the LatteCrema carafe before you pay, because the tier name alone will not tell you.

More on the Magnifica range in full, and choosing within the bean-to-cup category, is on the De'Longhi Magnifica hub and across the best super-automatic machines shortlist.